A 2015 study of Veterans Health Administration hospitals by Derickson, Fishman, Osatuke, and colleagues found that many employees said they would not report an error. Fear of retaliation was the most common reason. The finding has stayed with me because it points to something easy to miss: a workplace can look orderly while important truths remain unsaid. Fear works, and that's the problem. It can cause employees to keep their concerns to themselves and avoid drawing attention. For a while, it can look to those inside and outside the organization like everything is great. It may even look like agreement. But compliance is not the same as trust, and quiet is not the same as confidence.
Safety runs downhill. It is hard to ask people to be honest in a room where you are also afraid of what honesty might cost you. Managers are often expected to create trust and openness for their teams while carrying their own uncertainty, pressure, and limited control. What does fear cost a person at work? In short, everything. It may be the meeting where someone notices a problem and says nothing. The error nobody logs because reporting it feels more dangerous than hoping it goes unnoticed. The idea that dies in a parking lot on the way home, because the person who had it has learned that offering something new is not worth the exposure. All of this points to an environment where risks, mistakes, observations, and improvements are underreported or not reported at all. In essence, an echo chamber for whatever leader is running that business. In echo chambers, originality and innovation are stifled.
There is a reason that silence is so hard to interrupt, and it has something to do with how we are built. I’ve read that we’re wired, probably since the beginning of time, to remember negatives more vividly than positives. Think about it - during a performance review, if your boss tells you seven things you did well and two things you could improve upon, which ones do you focus on? Exactly! It’s why it’s important that supervisors realize the best way to get the best out of employees and, therefore, the organization isn’t through fear, but through feedback.
I used to coach high school basketball. When a player was getting pressured and turned the ball over, I had a choice in how to handle it. I could yell at them, “Stop turning the ball over!” Fear-based. Or I could ask them what they are seeing. Feedback-based. The second option allows them to communicate with you. The communication opens the door to understanding and growth. Yelling closes any door to development. A few weeks ago, I was talking to someone, and they asked me, “Who yells in today’s environment?” Honestly, you’d be surprised. However, I don’t think you’d be surprised at how ineffective it is.
Some people will read this and think I’m asking for no accountability. That couldn’t be further from the truth. If you give feedback all the time, it stops being feedback and becomes just how you communicate. If I wait for the perfect moment to tell you all that you’re doing wrong, I'm not only ineffective at providing feedback; I’m also creating a pattern of “Gotcha” supervision that creates angst the next time feedback is given.
If you’re a supervisor today, ask yourself: if you had 10 opportunities to give feedback in the course of a day, how many of them are achieving the desired result? If it’s less than half, pause and revise your approach by starting with feedback on what IS working, so when you need to share what isn't, it is received as intended. You and your team will get better at giving and receiving feedback, and the people you lead will start to hear it as help rather than a threat.
It took me years to understand this lesson. I only hope I’m a better leader today because of the mistakes I made yesterday. And I hope I am a better leader tomorrow, because I’m willing to continue learning new and better ways to treat employees with dignity and humanity.
Coach Ha-Keem

